Why are you only opened for lunch?

Everything at Fayetteville Pie Company is made fresh.  After our 11-3 lunch service, we begin preparations for the next day.


Do you cater?

Fayetteville Pie Company can accommodate small events and gatherings. Please call 910-483-4097 for more information.


Do you host private parties?

Interested in having an exclusive, after hours party at Fayetteville Pie Company? 
Renting the space is $100 an hour with a two hour minimum. Payment is required in advance to hold the date and time.

The menu will vary depending on what we are serving that day. A vegetarian option can be provided upon request ahead of time. Your guests will be able to choose from the three savory pies and the three sweet pies on the menu. Pies will be baked fresh and will be served approximately 20 minutes after the orders have been placed. Your guests can pay individually or you can pay for everything with the credit card on file. 

How often do you change your menu?

We change our menu frequently. We have an ever increasing number of delicious pies that we rotate in and out. There's usually a daily or weekly change. The updated  menu is posted at about 8:30 each morning on Instagram, Facebook, and on our website.  If you "like" us on Facebook and follow us on Instagram, you will see the daily menu in your feed.


Are any of your pies Gluten free?

We do offer several glutenless pies that rotate on our menu from time to time. We say gluten less, rather than gluten free because we use flour in our kitchen. At this time, we do not offer any dairy free, soy free, or sugar free pies. The gloves we use to prepare and handle food at FPC are latex free and powder free. 


Do you take orders for pick up?

Yes. We take orders online in four convenient ways: through our website, through our Facebook page, Instagram, and through our Free App. You can download our App by texting FAYETTEVILLE to 33733.  Once you've placed your order and paid, you can avoid the line and come to the pick up counter for your order.  

Do you deliver?

We partner with Postmates and FayToGo for our delivery service. Download the Postmates App or go to the FayToGo website.


Do you take reservations?

Our dining room is first come, first serve. If you plan on meeting up with a large group for lunch, it's best to send someone in a little ahead of time to save the seats. We do fill up fast, but if you plan to come in at 11, when we first open, you shouldn't have a problem.


Do you ship pies?

Currently, we do not ship our pies. We take great pride in serving food that is fresh and of a high quality.  We are researching methods of shipping that  that will maintain the integrity of our food. 


Is Fayetteville Pie Company a chain restaurant?

No. FPC is locally owned and operated by two military veterans. We love Fayetteville and wanted to bring something unique to the community. Pie is a wonderful comfort food, and a universal symbol of home. 


We also offer FREE WiFi   Connect with @FayPieCo Free WiFi